The Morality Of Violence

Editorials

There are any number of justifications for human beings killing each other, in waging war to punishing criminals.

There are any number of justifications for humans killing animals, from murder by proxy in the markeplace to killing for fun in the field.

Justifications are similarly raised in defense of exploiting both people and animals, just as rationalizations were used to justify human slavery in the past and animal slavery in the present.

The ostensible reasons, while universally proffered, are seen to be specious on even cursory examination.

Humans raise law, necessity, private property, religion, tradition, individual freedom, etc, as justifications for the exploitation and murder of both people and animals.

But none of those rationalizations is the ultimate reason that human violence is visited upon others or upon animals.

The reason for all violence is simple: Humans have the power to commit violence, and neither the weak nor the unorganized (nor the animals) can prevent it being done to them.

Institutionalized violence has been the province of most governments and of the oligarchs that control most governments. It is carried out by armies, corporations, police forces and legal systems.,

It is taught in the schools and in the pulpits, extolled by the media and political leaders.

And it will never end under our Capitalist system or under our fascist governments.

Only Socialism proposes —carries the ideology and value system—to tear down the institutions of exploitation and violence.

Only Socialism advocates for the victims of the oppressive capitalist system which controls most of the world.

Only Socialism eliminates the incentives for exploitation, and advocates to protect the weak, the disenfranchized, and the unorganized.

Constructing true socialism offers the best prospect to end human and nonhuman exploitation in our long-suffering world.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

roland-macaw

 Roland Vincent, a socialist and dedicated animal liberationist, is currently in charge of covering the intersection between ecoanimal and socialist questions, hoping to make clear to both sides that an alliance is a natural and mutually beneficial development.  He runs several pages and groups on Facebook, including Animal Rights & the Environment, Roland’s Raiders, and others. 

 




Police chase bear through Ohio city [Video & comment]

bearYiungstown

A black bear was spotted roaming a highly populated section of Youngstown, Ohio on Sunday. WKBN-TV’s Nadine Grimley reports on the efforts to keep the animal out of harm’s way.  The fact the bear was not immediately executed is the real news in this item, and for that the police called on the scene and officials who may have played a role in this “conflict resolution” deserve plenty of credit.

As a rule, humans, and especially fearful job-concerned bureaucrats, condemn any animal that presents the slightest threat to humans and their activities to death.  “You can’t be sufficiently and proactively protective when it comes to risk to human life, ” seems to be the prevailing philosophy.  Fact is, being a mere “nuisance’ can also land an animal on the executioner’s scaffold. This is standard operating procedure even when it’s obvious the animal meant no harm, as is often the case with a mother who was simply defending her “safety perimeter” from intruders. So, again, kudos to the police in this case, and let’s see this attitude become the new standard operating procedure. —P. Greanville

A similar incident was reported about a tear ago in Southern New Jersey/ Phila area. Go to page 2 to read the full report.

On Wednesday, NJ wildlife officials said they planned to let a black bear that was roaming about Burlington County alone.  But early Thursday morning, he was laying in a net, face-down, after having been tranquilized with a dart gun.  He was spotted in a backyard just a few hundred yards from a Delran nursery school.

Over the past week, witnesses reported seeing the bear swimming in Strawbridge Lake in Moorestown, eating seeds from bird feeders, and roaming through parts of Mount Laurel, Moorestown, Maple Shade, Westampton and Florence.  They estimated he was 4-foot-tall and weighed about 400 pounds.

They weren’t far off.  Once captured and sedated, the bear was weighed and measured.  He was 360 pounds – and 6-foot-tall.  Even more surprising, he had a tag in his ear that showed he was the same bear that was roaming about Vineland a year ago.  At that time, he was also captured and relocated.

This time, the bear is being set free in Shamong, a community that dips into the Pinelands in the northeast region of Burlington County.

Wildlife officials initially hoped that he would just pass through the county and find his way to a woods during his search for new territory.  He would be trapped and moved away only if he exhibited aggressive behavior, they said.

But when Delran police received a call Thursday morning from residents who said a bear was in standing in their backyard, in a very populated area, close to the busy Route 130 and the KinderCare nursery school, wildlife officials changed their mind.  They recommended the police go there and try to shoo him up a tree.  Then, they shot him with darts to make him drowsy and they caught him in a net when he fell to the ground.

As he lay sleeping on a tarp, waiting to be put into a truck to be relocated, he actually looked tame.  And cute.  His chest had a fluffy tuft of white.   Spectators oohed and ahhed.  They cheered when police lifted him and safely put him into the truck.

The bear had never become menacing.  But he made one mistake.  He waded too deep into suburbia where he may have either been hit in traffic or where he may have come up upon a child.  He’s being returned to the woods for everyone’s safety, including his.  But who knows if he’ll stay there.

Written by Inquirer staff writer Jan Hefler, the Burlco Buzz blog covers breaking news in the the county, as well as its quirky characters, crime cases, politics, outdoor recreation and environment. 

Contact Jan at jhefler@phillynews.com.
Read more at http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/burlington/Black-Bear-Is-Captured-Despite-Plans-To-Let-It-Be.html#OkDQJGE1GfGPxIxP.99

Read more at http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/burlington/Black-Bear-Is-Captured-Despite-Plans-To-Let-It-Be.html#zoP6VfYC5YwMSgws.99




Genocide in Indonesian Zoo

The Fate of Animals
Like all fascist failed states incubated by America, most people in Indonesia live and die for a few rich individuals and clans, and for market fundamentalism.

ChandrikaTiger

by ANDRE VLTCHEK
Simulpost with Counterpunch

Indonesians are no amateurs when it comes to mass murder and genocides.

They managed to slaughter with their bare hands, between 1 and 3 million people in 1965/66, mainly those who belonged to the educated class, and of course the Communists, teachers, artists and members of the Chinese minority.

They butchered and tortured to death around 30 percent of the inhabitants of what is now Timor-Leste. And they have already exterminated at least 150,000 men, women and children in Papua, in an ongoing and totally hushed up genocide that allows Western countries to access its natural resources. 150,000 corpses is, of course, one of the lower estimates…

One could say that with such a record and such an absolute lack of compassion even towards their fellow human beings, the fate of the animals killed regularly all over Indonesia, should not come as something surprising or shocking.

bear in distress

bear

Chandrika

tortured babies of Komodo dragon

welcome to Surabaya zoo

Andre Vltchek is a novelist, filmmaker and investigative journalist. He has covered wars and conflicts in dozens of countries. His discussion with Noam Chomsky On Western Terrorism is now going to print. His critically acclaimed political novel Point of No Return is now re-edited and available. Oceania is his book on Western imperialism in the South Pacific. His provocative book about post-Suharto Indonesia and the market-fundamentalist model is called “Indonesia – The Archipelago of Fear”. He has just completed the feature documentary, “Rwanda Gambit” about Rwandan history and the plunder of DR Congo. After living for many years in Latin America and Oceania, Vltchek presently resides and works in East Asia and Africa. He can be reached through his website or his Twitter.




Break out the champagne! Non-animal meat makes its debut on NBC’s Today Show

NBC’s Craig Melvin reported on the Beyond Meat breakthrough, and challenged Matt Lauer, Al Roker, Carson, Tamron and the rest of the anchors to identify it in a taste-test. (Spoiler: They failed.)
Patrice Greanville

meatlessMeat-NBCToday

What may well be one of the biggest media events of the decade (or century!) took place almost under the radar on NBC’s Today Show in late April (2014).  That morning Beyond Meat joined the Today Show crew for a two-part segment on Beyond Meat, a new manufacturer of a variety of plant-based animal “meats” that can definitely fool the palate. 

The list of advantages is impressive, but the most colossal part of this breakthrough is the potential it carries for our planet and most of its living creatures—humans and nonhumans. Among humans—aside from people who have long consumed meat substitutes for ethical or health reasons—many seek an alternative to a food addiction that forces them to consume animals, incurring frequent moral pangs and contributing wittingly to the destruction of a gravely besieged environment.

For non-human animals the arrival of meat substitutes of Beyond Meat quality, represents a potential liberation from the horrors of factory farming and other forms of animal husbandry destined for the abattoir. If non-animal meats advance in popularity, the enslavement, torture and death of countless creatures just to become food on a human platter will no longer prove necessary.

Nonmeat burger. Impossible to distinguish.

Nonmeat burger. Impossible to distinguish.

For the planet itself, this is also enormously important news. A variety of ecological disasters are directly linked to meat consumption: ranching that destroys primeval forests, ecosystems, and displaces aboriginal peoples; runoffs that pollute rivers and oceans (the Gulf of Mexico a prime example), eventually toxifying most of our waterways; the destruction of the land by creating gigantic waste lagoons and other misuses; and massive reliance on antibiotics to prevent disease flareups in tightly confined animals, a practice which degrades the ability of antibiotics to combat infections, and introduces these substances into the human genetic pool with calamitous consequences.

Those are just some of the utilitarian benefits. For those of us who work on animal liberation out of sheer compassion, and a belief that our planet deserves better, there’s also major cause for celebration. Now we know that history is on our side, at least on this issue.

On the Today Show

The first part had Ethan taking Craig Melvin on a tour of the Beyond Meat facility in Colombia, Missouri to give them a look where the Bill Gates endorsed “Future of Food” is being made each day and being shipped out nationwide to stores like Whole Foods, Sprouts, HEB, Publix and thousands of other stores including soon to be Safeway, Target and more!

The next part took the tour back to the NYC studio with the whole Today Show crew including Matt Lauer and Al Roker as they sit down to taste our Beyond Beef Chili and Sesame Beyond Chicken Salad live as it goes up against a dish created from animal proteins.

The segment aired at 8am local time nationwide. Beyond Meat’s Today Show debut was a complete success. We hope they change how America meats, one bite at a time!

FINAL COMMENT
—P. Greanville is editor in chief of The Greanville Post

SELECT AUDIENCE COMMENTS

Absolutely wonderful news that the two taste-tested products fooled the Today Hosts … perhaps that will convince their carnivore viewers to finally try non-meat alternatives. As a vegetarian I have been pushing Morning Star and other well-made, meatless products, and welcome these new products. Although the healthier aspects will win over many, – including that they are non-GMO and gluten free, I am happiest that they may finally dampen the ever growing demand for chicken and beef, both of which have horrible consequences for the animals and the planet.




Angela Davis: Leading the Left on Animal Rights

angela-older

I cannot overemphasize how significant this is.
The coming of age of the AR movement!
The beginning of the movement as a political force.
Animal Rights becoming part of the Left’s agenda.
Share with everyone you know!

The three most important developments in the Animal Rights movement have been:

1.  The movement began.

2.  Angela Davis joined it.

3.  Everything else.

Please share this widely. This is the turning point!

Perhaps the most important development so far in the struggle for Animal Rights just occurred.

A little noticed, under-reported, and largely ignored report will shake the movement (and its myriad observers and deriders) to its core.

Many Animal Rights activists have been working to raise awareness among our troops that the movement is philosophically a Leftist one.

My primary mission has been to argue for, and facilitate, broad Left wing coalitions. I believe the animals’ interests are best served by those who also believe in human rights, freedom, democracy, and an end to the capitalist system which promotes and profits through animal exploitation, enslavement, and murder.

While some of us may have credibility and influence within the Animal Rights movement, we have little with the Left as a whole.

And just as important as it is to have AR activists aware of their role in the Left, is making Liberals, Progressives, Socialists, and others on the Left aware of the need to oppose all types of oppression, not just that aimed at our human brothers and sisters.

We have not had a leader of the Left stand with Animal Rights atcivists, UNTIL NOW!

And do we have one!

Angela Davis, probably the most famous, influential, and ethical leader of the Left in America is now the most pivotal person in the Animal Rights movement.  I recently shared the article, below, from counterpunch.org

.

.

“The food we eat masks so much cruelty”…

Vegan Angela Davis Connects Human and Animal Liberation
.

By JON HOCHSCHARTNER, Counterpunch
Jan. 24, 2014

While Angela Davis is well known for her progressive perspectives on race, gender, and class, less well known are her views on species, which are quite forward-thinking. The great socialist scholar, it might surprise some to hear, does not consume animal products.

“I usually don’t mention that I’m vegan but that has evolved,” Davis said at the 27th Empowering Women of Color Conference, according to a transcript available at RadioProject.org. “I think it’s the right moment to talk about it because it is part of a revolutionary perspective – how can we not only discover more compassionate relations with human beings but how can we develop compassionate relations with the other creatures with whom we share this planet and that would mean challenging the whole capitalist industrial form of food production.”

Challenging this form of food production, Davis said, would involve witnessing animal exploitation firsthand. “It would mean being aware – driving up the interstates or driving down the 5, driving down to LA, seeing all the cows on the ranches,” she stated. “Most of people don’t think about the fact they’re eating animals. When they’re eating a steak or eating chicken, most people don’t think about the tremendous suffering that those animals endure simply to become food products to be consumed by human beings.”

For Davis, this blindness is connected to the commodity form. “I think the lack of critical engagement with the food that we eat demonstrates the extent to which the commodity form has become the primary way in which we perceive the world,” she said. “We don’t go further than what Marx called the exchange value of the actual object- we don’t think about the relations that that object embodies- and were important to the production of that object, whether it’s our food or our clothes or our iPads or all the materials we use to acquire an education at an institution like this. That would really be revolutionary to develop a habit of imagining the human relations and non-human relations behind all of the objects that constitute our environment.”

Davis struck a similar note in a video recording uploaded to the Vegans of Color blog.

“I don’t talk about this a lot but I’m going to do this today because I think it’s really important,” she said. “The food we eat masks so much cruelty. The fact that we can sit down and eat a piece of chicken without thinking about the horrendous conditions under which chickens are industrially bred in this country is a sign of the dangers of capitalism, how capitalism has colonized our minds. The fact that we look no further than the commodity itself, the fact that we refuse to understand the relationships that underly the commodities that we use on a daily basis. And so food is like that.”

Davis suggested viewers watch the film ‘Food, Inc.’ “And then ask yourself,” she said, “what is it like to sit down and eat that food that is generated only for the purposes of profit and creates so much suffering?”

Davis concluded her comments by explicitly linking the treatment of humans and animals.

“I think there is a connection between, and I can’t go further than this, the way we treat animals and the way we treat people who are at the bottom of the hierarchy,” She said. “Look at the ways in which people who commit such violence on other human beings have often learned how to enjoy that by enacting violence on animals. So there are a lot of ways we can talk about this.”

Jon Hochschartner is a freelance writer from upstate New York. Visit his website at JonHochschartner.com.