RICKY HALE—Alternatively, the real killer never went to the woods and the rifle is a decoy. The simplest explanation is usually correct and it’s hard to explain how Robinson is the killer without tying yourself in knots.
How did he get onto the roof and reassemble a complex rifle so quickly with a screwdriver, recalibrate the sights, and also change his clothes?! How did he reassemble the rifle in the woods without the screwdriver and why did he bother? (Remember, gun experts are saying this would be highly difficult, if not impossible, even with the screwdriver.)
We are told that after the killing, Robinson returned to the woods to drop off the gun, placing it in a box that he wrapped in a towel. He was not carrying the box, so he must have returned to the exact spot to locate the box. Why slow down the get away like that?

